Showing posts with label US Administration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Administration. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Better Late Than Never Comment: On Bill Burns as Deputy Secretary of State

This is week-old news now, but, uh, something must have been happening in the Mideast, or something, so I'm just getting around to commenting. Deputy Secretary of State James Steinberg, number two to Secretary Clinton, is stepping down, and she has named Under Secretary of State William Burns, the number three man and a career Foreign Service Officer, as the new Deputy Secretary.

Under Secretary Burns is a former Ambassador to Jordan and a former Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs. (He later served as Ambassador to Russia, but I'm focusing on his Mideast expertise.) He's got some command of Arabic and a lot of experience in the region. (Full disclosure: when he was first going out to Jordan in 1998 I actually met and briefed him, with a group of others, a bit, and met him a couple of more times when he was at NEA; I won't claim we're friends, but I have dealt with him.) Looking at a list of Deputy Secretaries of State, I have to say he has more Mideast experience than any of his predecessors, which ought to be a good thing. In fact of them all, only Richard Armitage had real experience in the region, and that fairly late in his career. (I know him too, and once worked for him briefly, helping him start a newsletter when he was in private sector consulting. I'm not trying to name drop, but to flag my own potential pre-judgments and biases.)

Of course, the Deputy Secretary is at the service of the Secretary, and does not make policy himself or herself. But it will be useful to have someone with real experience of the region so well placed. I think. Even if I'm a week late in commenting.
You have read this article US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/04/better-late-than-never-comment-on-bill.html. Thanks!
Monday, March 28, 2011

Obama's Speech: First Take

Some initial thoughts on the President's speech [If you haven't seen it, transcript here; embedded video at end of this post.]:
  • While I'm sure the domestic debate will continue, I think it was a good speech in its attempt to say this is an international commitment; the goal is to get rid of Qadhafi but it isn't our military mission, which is winding down.
  • US interests and values were emphasized up front; regional concerns at the end. We can't bear the brunt alone. Perhaps a bit of overemphasis that it's NATO's issue now. NATO has decided to add protection of civilians to the military mission, not us. Last time I looked, we're a member of NATO.
  • Only a 30 minute speech (some say because ABC didn't want to preempt Dancing with the Stars): why from NDU rather than the Oval Office? Probably to assist military credibility.
  • I noted with interest that he said we had to act quickly to prevent the fall of Benghazi, a city of 700,000, "a city nearly the size of Charlotte." Why the choice of Charlotte? It' s a nice city, the banking capital of the South, but other cities in the 700,000 range include Fort Worth, Detroit, El Paso, Memphis, Baltimore, Boston . . . Do you suppose this could have anything to do with the 2012 Democratic Party Convention being in Charlotte? Surely just a coincidence.
Here's the video:

You have read this article Libya / NATO / Obama / US Administration / US military with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/03/obama-speech-first-take.html. Thanks!
Monday, March 14, 2011

The Distraction Factor

I suspect the "GCC" intervention in Bahrain — which apparently consists of about 1000 Saudi forcesa — while a direct response to the worsening of the situation yesterday, also is taking advantage of the fact that, in the wake of the Japanese earthquake/tsunami/nuclear disasters, the world's media attention is focused elsewhere. While most major news networks deployed heavily to the Mideast in the past few months, the big names have moved on to Japan, while those remaining in the Mideast have to also cover both sides in the Libyan war. Yemeni forces have been using greater force with the protesters as well, in part because the whole world is now occupied elsewhere.

A more disturbing thought is that the world's distraction may not be the only reason governments are cracking down harder on the protests: despite the Arab League's unprecedented support for a No-Fly Zone in Libya, beleaguered autocrats may be emulating Qadhafi on the assumption that a hard line still works. I'm not sure that it does in the long run, but it may in the short run.

The US response is going to be interesting. A lot of Bahraini opposition figures have already noted that US Defense Secretary Gates was just there on Saturday. I don't believe it's cause and effect, but many in the region may well jump to that conclusion.
You have read this article Bahrain / Saudi Arabia / US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/03/distraction-factor.html. Thanks!
Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Salih: I Didn't Mean it, Really!

Yesterday, Yemen's beleaguered President ‘Ali ‘Abdullah Salih took the traditional route in explaining the demonstrations against him: he blamed the US and Israel. After the White House criticized the comments, and perhaps on reflecting that the US is, right now, just about his Best Friend Remaining (unlike Libya, Al-Qa‘ida really is active in Yemen) , today he called the US National Security Adviser to apologize for any "misunderstanding" his remarks might have caused. Like so many other leaders who've held the same job since well back in the last century (1978 in Salih's case, longer than Mubarak but less than Qadhafi), he may still tend to forget that the 24/7 satellite news channels, the Internet, and Twitter aren't going to let you say one thing to your domestic audience and another to your foreign allies, like you could get away with back in the good old days.

And now, there are reports that Salih has agreed to a plan that would call for him to step down by the end of the year.

I'm sure the opposition will remember that he has changed his mind before (he promised not to run in 2006, was "persuaded" to change his mind, and won 77% of the vote), so I'm not sure a promise about what he'll do 10 months from now will sell to the folks in the streets, even if he's sold it to the opposition parties.
You have read this article US Administration / Yemen with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/03/salih-i-didn-mean-it-really.html. Thanks!
Friday, February 18, 2011

Bahrain: the US Dilemma

What to say about Bahrain? Unlike Egypt or Tunisia, my knowledge of the country is superficial. But even more than in Egypt, the growing violence in the country and the bloody response of the authorities produces a dilemma for US policy. Not only is it unclear whether this will end well for US interests; it is unclear whether it can end well. The contradictory elements within the strategic gambles the US has made in the region, but particularly in the Gulf, may finally be coming home to roost, and the fact that Bahrain is in question involves not only critical US interests in the island nation itself (the base of the US Fifth Fleet), but also the elephant in the living room: Bahrain's neighbor at the other end of the King Fahd Causeway. And that goes to the heart of US policy in the Gulf. American sympathy for protesters demanding democracy, unarmed protesters being fired on with live ammunition, is in direct conflict with two countervailing US interests: diminishing Iranian influence on the Arab side of the Gulf, and maintaining the crucial relations with Saudi Arabia, the cornerstone of US Gulf security policy since the fall of the Shah 32 years ago this month.

This is not a partisan US issue. The Saudi relationship was a cornerstone of US policy under both Democratic and Republican Administrations. It still is. Dating as it does from the fact that it was American oil companies (as opposed to British elsewhere in the Gulf) that controlled the Saudi concessions, the Saudi relationship has been sound since FDR's day. That the Bush family, including both Bush Presidents, were close to the Saudis is well known, but it was that human rights crusader Jimmy Carter who, toasting the Shah not long before his toppling, praised Iran as one of the Gulf's twin pillars of stability. The Clinton and Obama Administrations have upheld the centrality of the Saudi relationship to US strategic interests in the Gulf.

But there may be no country in the world — and I explicitly include Israel here — where US and Saudi interests potentially might conflict more than in Bahrain. The Saudis backed Husni Mubarak to the end, but they've had disagreements with Egypt before, especially in the Nasser era. But for the Saudis, Bahrain is literally too close to home. It is both an outlet (where a Saudi can get a drink and enjoy other pleasures unavailable at home by driving across a causeway) and a potential blowback threat: if Bahrain's Shi‘ite majority were to take power from the Sunni monarchy, the substantial Shi‘ite population in Saudi Arabia's Eastern Province might become restive, as they did in 1979 after the Iranian Revolution. And the Eastern Province is where the oil, the refineries, the pipeline heads, the oil ports, almost all of the industry, is based. The Saudis are likely to back the King of Bahrain to the hilt, but unless there is some progress towards dialogue and away from bloodshed in Bahrain, the US may face an insoluble dilemma.

If Bahrain's Shi‘ite majority were to actually control the country's policies (with or without continuing the Sunni monarchy), that would not automatically mean it would become pro-Iranian; while some Bahraini Shi‘ites are of Persian origin, the majority are Arab. But implacable Saudi hostility to a Shi‘ite-dominated Bahraini government might give a representative government nowhere else to turn. The Shi‘ite government of Iraq has its own problems. Forced to choose between Bahrain and Saudi Arabia, the US would have little choice but to side with the Saudis, however unpopular such a choice would be.

Finding some formula for negotiations and genuine liberalization that does not overtly threaten the Saudis' own security would be the ideal policy to pursue in Bahrain, but little of what has happened in the last 48 hours suggest any eagerness on the part of the King to do so. And he is no doubt hearing frequently from the neighbors across the causeway urging him to hang tough.

This will be a three-day holiday weekend in the US, with Monday off. I doubt if events will wait till Tuesday, but weekend posting will be limited to critical events.
You have read this article Bahrain / Egypt / Saudi Arabia / US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/02/bahrain-us-dilemma.html. Thanks!
Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Angry Arab on Fall of the State Department Arabists

As'ad AbuKhalil, the Angry Arab, is angry again. Assistant Secretary of State Jeffrey Feltman wrote a letter to The New York Times recently, taking exception to a favorable article about the Lebanese newspaper al-Akhbar (which has been the main Wikileaks outlet in Arabic), and praising instead the murdered Editor of al-Nahar. AbuKhalil offers a lengthy post which is essentially a critique of Feltman (though al-Nahar gets the treatment, too) and a yearning for the days of the Arabists at State, whose eclipse he dates to the Clinton Administration. While he acknowledges the State Department Arabists were oftn, in his view, too timid, and also often ignored, he has kind things to say about the late Richard Parker, as well as Richard Murphy and William Quandt. It's true that few of our most senior diplomats today have their rich knowledge of the region.

I don't agree with him 100%, but he has some useful points. He calls Robert Pelletreau the last Assistant Secretary for Near East who was an Arabist, which may be strictly accurate but may be misleading. It's also misleading to suggest that every policy figure in the Clinton Administration was a strong supporter of Israel. Martin Indyk and Dennis Ross are the usual targets here, but more balanced views were heard from Assistant Secretaries Ned Walker and Bill Burns, not to mention Aaron David Miller, who is too often assumed by critics to be an echo of Dennis Ross, which Miller's writings since leaving government service ought to put to rest.

But then, AbuKhalil has long enjoyed the role of provocateur, and I think he has succeeded in provoking some discussions here. It's worth a read. And I say that as someone who has never worked for the State Department, but who has never run away from the title of "Arabist."
You have read this article blogs and blogging / US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/01/angry-arab-on-fall-of-state-department.html. Thanks!
Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Wikileaks Does Egypt

Last week I made clear I have reservations about the whole Wikileaks enterprise, but also criticized the notion that once documents have been published, one should somehow ignore them as the US is urging government employees to do. The last couple of days' releases have started to include a number related to the Egyptian succession, a subject of continuing interest on this blog. Most are cables from the Ambassadorships of Francis Ricciardone (2005-2008) and Margaret Scobey (2008-present). Among some of interest:

Mubarak also offered insights into the character of his younger son, Gamal, whom he described as a perfectionist from childhood. "As a schoolboy, if I gave him a notebook with one line that was not straight, he would throw a fit and demand a new one," Mubarak laughed. Furthermore, Gamal is "idealistic" and "punctual." Mubarak added, "If he (Gamal) says, 'meet me for lunch at 2:00,' he means 2:00. Set your watch by it."


I think that these cables bear out what I've said previously: classified or not, there's not much new here for those who've been discussing this stuff for years, though the personal anecdote is both a nice touch and makes Gamal seem a bit strange. The potential successors, the personalities involved, etc. are all pretty well known. But it's interesting to see it in an official document, of course.

You have read this article Egypt / Gamal Mubarak / Husni Mubarak / US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2010/12/wikileaks-does-egypt.html. Thanks!
Friday, December 3, 2010

Clinton: We'll Reconsider Manas Air Base Role in 2014

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, visiting the Manas Air Base in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan, has indicated that the US presence on the base will be reconsidered once US forces disengage from Afghanistan in 2014, as they hope to do. She indicated that a key jet fuel contract would go to a Kyrgyz company, obviously a sweetener for keeping the base, which has been a real bargaining chip between the US and Russia and Kyrgyzstan, where internal dynamics and foreign politics have kept the fate of Manas, a key logistical support base for the Afghan War, in play.

Among her comments:
Well, it is great to see all of you here and thanks for letting me come by and say thank you. Colonel, thanks for those kind words and it’s a great opportunity – I can see some Christmas decorations already going up back there – to express to you our appreciation for what you do every single day on behalf of our country. I just had some good visits with the president [Roza Otunbayeva, shown in pic above left with Clinton] and other officials of the government here, and then I just had the opportunity to meet with a large group of students and take a lot of questions about the United States, about our policies, about this air base, and to tell the people of Kyrgyzstan that we are going to support them as they try to establish a democratic state.

This has been a challenging year for them, and the United States has been with them, providing humanitarian assistance and other support, and we will continue to do so. They live in a region where there is not very much democracy, as you know. And part of our strong belief is that the United States has demonstrated conclusively that a democratic system that establishes the rule of law, that respects diversity, that gives people a chance to live their dreams, is by far the better system for anybody. It doesn’t matter where your country is or who you are or what your background might be.

And that’s part of the reason why you’re here. I want to thank the men and women of the 376th Air Expeditionary Wing. I want to thank all of our soldiers, sailors, Marines, and airmen who are in transit to or from Afghanistan. We greatly appreciate what you’re doing. We think it is of critical benefit to advance the interests and the security of the United States, but also of countries like Kyrgyzstan and this region as well.



You have read this article Kyrgyzstan / Manas / US Administration with the title US Administration. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2010/12/clinton-we-reconsider-manas-air-base.html. Thanks!

Labels

1956 Suez War 1973 War 1st Amendment About the Blog Abraham Abu Dhabi Afghanistan agriculture Ahmadinejad Ahmed Mansour airlines Al-Jazeera Al-Qa‘ida Algeria Alzheimer’s AmeriCorps ancient history Anwar Sadat ANZACs appliance rebate April 15 AQAP Arab League Arab newspapers Arab World Arab-Americans Arab-Israeli Issues Arabic language archaeology Asads Ashraf Marwan atrazine Ausrtralia Ayman Nour back pain Bahrain bailouts bank assets to GDP bank capital bank guarantees bank nationalisation Barack Obama being a patient Berbers bethlehem bias billionaires biodiversity Biography birther blahs Blankfein blog action day blogs and blogging books BP brain cancer brain injury brainless bratwurst breast cancer breast cancer Britain Buckley v. Valeo Budget 2009 bully business Cairo camels cancer cancer bonds cancer cause cancer cure cancer detection cancer diagnosis cancer research cancer risk cancer treatment Capital Flows carbon footprint care giving Catholic Church censorship CEO pay Chamber of Commerce chemo brain chemotherapy child abuse China chlorine Christmas Citizens United Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission climate change climate science clinical trials coal coal power coffeehouse gossip college colon cancer colonialism communication Congress Constellation Brands Constitution coping Copts corporations corruption coups credibility Credit Crunch credit default swaps CSAs Cuba cure death debt debt crisis defense issues deficits democratization derivatives DFL diet diglossia Diplomacy distractions doctor appointments doctor questions doctors Don Gordon donating Double Dip Druze Dubai Earth Day earthquakes East Asia and the Middle East economics Egypt ElBaradei elbow elections emotions energy Eurozone Growth Eurozone Spreads exercises extinction fairness Fallujah fat fatigue FDR Federal Reserve film Finance First World War Fiscal Stimulus food football Fox News France fraud Friday Prayer friends funding Gallo Gamal Mubarak Garrison Keillor Gaza GCC Geopolitics George W. Bush Ghajar Global Imbalances global warming Golden Rule Goldman Sachs GOP government debt Greece Greenland Gulf oil spill Gulf states Haiti Hajj Hamas Hariri head injury healing Health health care health care reform health insurance healthcare healthcare reform healthiness healthy eating healthy living Hebron hedge funds Helen Thomas helping herbicides Herding Hizbullah holidays holy places http://www.blogger.com/img/blank.ghttp://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gifif http://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gif humanity humor Husni Mubarak IDF Imazighen income tax incompetence Indian Ocean inflation information technology injections insider trading insolvency insurance intelligence Internet Iran Iraq Iraq war Ireland Islam Islamophobia Israel Israeli newspapers Israeli politics Italy Japan Jerusalem Jim Klobuchar Jordan Judaism Jundallah Koch Industries Kurdish issues Kuwait Kyrgyzstan labor lack of sleep languages learning Lebanon Leukimia levothyroxine Libya life lists Lung cancer Maghreb Maldives Manas Maronites masters of manipulation Mauritania Mecca media medical costs medical errors medical history medical information medication MEI MEI Annual Conference meltdown metastatic cancer Middle East Journal Middle Eastern Christians military affairs Minnesota Minnesota GreenCorps Minnesota taxes monetary policy Morocco mortality Mossad Motivasi Muhammad Naguib Muqtada al-Sadr music music videos Muslim Brotherhood mzerim n Napa Nasser national anthems NATO needles Netanyahu New Deal New York New Zealand news NFL nitrogen pollution no-fly zone Non Sequitur normal nostalgia Nowruz nuclear crisis nuclear weapons Obama obituaries ocean acidification oil Oman Omar Suleiman oncologist optimism organic output gap ovarian cancer overscheduled pain Pakistan Palestine Palestinian Authority palliative Pat Robertson patient rights patriotism Pawlenty Pays d'Oc pesticides pink washing Pinot Noir Plan B planning PLO politics Pope Shenouda III Portfolios Prediction Markets prescriptions press freedom price of risk procedures prostate cancer prostitution protests Public Debt Qadhafi Qatar Quantitative Easing Qur'an radioactive iodine Ras al-Khaimah Ray McGovern Reagan recalls Recession recommendations recurrence remembrance Republican Party research revolutions Richard B. Parker rock bands royalty Rush Limbaugh Saad Zaghloul Saddam Hussein safety sanity Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad Satan Saudi Arabia scars Scott Walker Sectarianism settlements Shi‘ism Shin Bet shipping side effects skepticism Skin cancer sleep social justice social networking solar cells solar energy solar power soy Spare Capacity special operations sphagnum moss sports state budget stem cell Stephen Ross Wine Cellars Sterling Streisand Effect stress Stuxnet succession issues Sudan Summits Sunnis Super Bowl support Supreme Court surgery swimming pool Syria Tamazight Target Corp. Target stores tax cuts taxes teaching televangelism television Territorial disputes terrorism testing The ___ Gulf The UK think tanks thyroid cancer Tifinagh time tired Tom Emmer tourism transportation trauma travel Tulocay Winery Tunisia Turkey UAE UK fiscal policy UK Recession unions United Nations universities university US US Administration US Civil War US military US Presidential Election Utah vacation vegetables Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity Veteran's Day video volunteer volunteer work Walid Jumblatt Wall Street water wealth weather Weekend Historical Videos weight loss wellness Western Sahara Wikileaks wine Wisconsin women Woods Hole World War II Yemen YItzhak Rabin young cancer patients Zahi Hawass Zero Bound