Showing posts with label Muslim Brotherhood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Muslim Brotherhood. Show all posts
Friday, April 1, 2011

Egypt: Resurgent Salafism and Cautious MB-Coptic Feelers

This is obviously both an exciting and a very delicate time in Egypt, and secularists and Islamists alike are staking out their positions prior to the fall elections. Egypt's new interim constitutional declaration retains the existing ban on political parties based on religion, sect, or ethnicity, but the Muslim Brotherhood expects to create a political party that will pass the test, and compete in the elections. The Brotherhood has also announced its intention to create a satellite channel and a newspaper. The less centrally organized, but even more conservative, Salafi movement has also been very active, and their growing influence has alarmed secular Muslims, Christians, and the mystical Sufi orders. A brief roundup of links, since there's been too much going on to comment individually.

The Brotherhood has been reaching out to the Coptic Church, apparently to appear mainstream. Brotherhood General Guide Muhammad Badie has asked for a meeting with Coptic Pope Shenouda III, whom he telephoned after one of the Pope's frequent medical visits to the United States. Shenouda downplayed the request.The Brotherhood also wants to meet with the Coptic Youth Movement.

Meanwhile, Salafi movement demonstrators clashed with villagers over closing liquor stores and coffeehouses. and also demanded the "freeing" of Camillia Shehata, a Coptic priest's wife they believe tried to convert to Islam, and who they charge is being held against her will by the Church. On the day before the Salafi protest on the Shehata affair last Tuesday, a wild rumor spread among Christian and secular Muslim women claiming that the Salafis were going to kidnap unveiled women and hold them hostage until Shehata was freed. The Salafis issued a strong denial (link is in Arabic), and the ruling Military Council met with Pope Shenouda, to reassure the church.

The Wafd and other secular parties are talking about forming a secular alliance to compete with the Brotherhood and Salafi movements in the Parliamentary elections, while Salafis and Sufis are also clashing, with Salafis attacking Sufi shrines, and the council of Sufi Orders threatening a "war" against the Salafis if they continue to demolish shrines. The Sufi (Islamic mystical) orders venerate local saints and the sheikhs of their order, while the Salafis equate saint veneration with idolatry.

All of this ferment also coincides with efforts to organize the long-discussed Wasat or Center Party, led by younger Islamists disillusioned with the Muslim Brotherhood, even as the Brotherhood itself is reportedly riven by internal divisions. I've always thought that those who assumed the Muslim Brotherhood was going to be the obvious winner of the revolution were buying into Mubarak-era propaganda, since with real political pluralism, a wide spectrum of religious and secular movements are likely to take the field. The fact that the Brotherhood now seems to be just one religious movement among many may be bearing that out, though don't count them out since they still have the best organizational infrastructure.

Clearly, a number of religious/secular, fundamentalist/mystical, and Muslim/Christian fault lines are under stress.

I'll be back later with a lengthy historical post before disappearing for the weekend.
You have read this article Copts / Egypt / Middle Eastern Christians / Muslim Brotherhood / Pope Shenouda III / Sectarianism with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/04/egypt-resurgent-salafism-and-cautious.html. Thanks!
Thursday, February 24, 2011

Wasat: A Challenge to the Brotherhood?

For a great many years a moderate Islamist party in Egypt, the Wasat (center or centrist) Party has sought official recognition, which has been consistently denied. Formed by younger, disillusioned members of the Muslim Brotherhood, it could very well prove the moderate alternative to the Brotherhood that the Mubarak regime always kept from emerging, so as to make the Brotherhood the sole face of Islamist politics. Since the fall of Mubarak, the Wasat Party, which likes to compare itself to Turkey's ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) has finally won recognition.

Meanwhile, the Muslim Brotherhood itself is now preparing to form its own political party, apparently to be called the Freedom and Justice Party.
You have read this article Egypt / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/02/wasat-challenge-to-brotherhood.html. Thanks!
Thursday, February 3, 2011

Hard to Keep the Conspiracy Theories Straight

Both President Mubarak and Vice President Suleiman, talking to ABC News, today, insisted the Muslim Brotherhood is behind the upheaval in Egypt. Meanwhile, as noted in this story in Al-Masry al-Youm, Government sources appear to be behind rumors that the whole thing is an Israeli plot.

Ah, yes, the Israeli-Muslim Brotherhood Axis strikes again!

Israel, of course, seems to be Mubarak's strongest cheerleader right now.
You have read this article coffeehouse gossip / Egypt / Israel / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/02/hard-to-keep-conspiracy-theories.html. Thanks!
Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Stop Asking Me About the Muslim Brotherhood

I've had a fair number of interviews with media since Egypt erupted, not as many as MEI's Ned Walker, but enough to keep me busy. I don't think there's been a single journalist who hasn't asked about the Muslim Brotherhood, and many commentators seem to see it as the inevitable alternative to Mubarak. I don't agree and tell them to watch the Army instead, a far more potent force.

Some points to make about the Brotherhood:

  1. The idea that it's the only alternative is essentially a theme played upon by Mubarak, who uses it as the bete noire to argue that only authoritarian rule can prevent it from coming to power.
  2. Yet the government has for years refused recognition to the Wasat (Center, Middle) Party, a moderate Islamist Party made up of younger Islamists. In a genuinely open system, such parties could emerge to draw strength from the Brotherhood.
  3. Do you think the young demonstrators are really going to accept replacing a President for Life with a Supreme Guide?
  4. This is not the Brotherhood of Hasan al-Banna or Sayyid Qutb. Yes, that may be a ruse, but even if its lip-service to democracy is fake, mostly it's still a movement led by old men. The younger faces do exist, but I don't think they're what the demonstrators have in mind.
  5. Of course the Brotherhood will try to emerge in a dominant role. So will many other movements from left to right. The Brotherhood's organization may be better, but in a real, open competition I'm not sure they'd get more than 20% or so. I may be wrong, but then we've never had a fair test so long as they've been the only credible alternative. I think the demonstrators have given us a third alternative.
Ask me again when the political system is free. But let's stop seeing the Brotherhood as inevitable.
You have read this article Egypt / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/02/stop-asking-me-about-muslim-brotherhood.html. Thanks!
Wednesday, January 26, 2011

The Noticeable Absence of the Brotherhood

One aspect of the Egyptian demonstrations clearly goes against the government's favored narrative: that the only alternative to the regime is the Muslim Brotherhood, and we don't want that, do we? This is the usual response to calls for lifting the State of Emergency, democratization (look what happened in Gaza!) etc.

Watch the videos now all over YouTube and Facebook. Do you see any beards? Well, maybe a few beard-and-mustache looks of some young hipsters, but not the beard-without-mustache "uniform" we associate with the Muslim Brothers. Where was the Brotherhood? (Where is Husni Mubarak, of course, is the other question.)

The Brotherhood's English and Arabic websites have been reporting the events closely, and the MB issued a cautious statement that its membership could participate as long as they were peaceful and obeyed the law. But this is clearly a movement of young, secular, middle class Egyptians, or those who would be middle class if they could find jobs.

The Brotherhood may have calculated that their presence would hurt the protests (the absence of Islamists from the Tunisian revolution has been remarked upon), or they may just figure they'll be rounded up anyway and they might as well not make it worse. But it does go against the narrative, encouraged by the regime and by some others, that the only alternative to autocracy is political Islam. And when the regime tried to blame the MB anyway, they made themselves look ridiculous.

One of the spurs to the present demonstrations, along with Tunisia, is the New Year's bombing of the Coptic church in Alexandria, which has led to much popular feeling about the dangers of religious polarization. That may be another reason for the Brotherhood sitting this one out.
You have read this article Egypt / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2011/01/noticeable-absence-of-brotherhood.html. Thanks!
Thursday, December 16, 2010

Egypt's MB Expels its One MP

Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood has moved to formally expel the only MB candidate to win a seat in the Parliamentary elections, Magdy Ashour. Ashour was reportedly pressured by the government to stay in the race to lend credibility to the elections, despite the decision of the Muslim Brotherhood to boycott the runoff round of the elections.

Senior Brotherhood figures had warned for several days that Ashour did not represent the Brotherhood since they boycotted the vote and that if he took his seat he would only be representing himself. Ashour insisted that he won fairly, shares the Brotherhood's views, and denies that he was elected through irregularities. When he took his seat in the new Parliament, however, the Brotherhood moved against him.
You have read this article Egypt / elections / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2010/12/egypt-mb-expels-its-one-mp.html. Thanks!
Wednesday, December 1, 2010

MB, Wafd Pull Out of Runoffs

Both the Muslim Brotherhood and the Wafd have pulled out of the Egyptian runoffs on Sunday. As I noted earlier, their participation in the first round had given the government a certain credibility for the elections, despite widespread expectations of irregularities. Pulling out of the second round may amount to closing the barn door after the horses have fled, but it will embarrass the government a bit, perhaps.
You have read this article Egypt / elections / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2010/12/mb-wafd-pull-out-of-runoffs.html. Thanks!
Monday, November 29, 2010

Election Complaints Growing

Complaints about irregularities in Egyptian elections are routine, but yesterday's vote has produced unusually extensive claims of irregularities. As was already clear in the 2005 vote,the ubiquity of cell phone cameras and the rise of YouTube has made quick documentation easier, and now Twitter makes it instantaneous.

There will doubtless be more detail forthcoming. The government is admitting there were some irregularities bu claims the overall process was good, and is even quoting praise by foreign commentators (link is in Arabic). Opposition forces and human rights groups are telling a differen story.

The Egyptian Organization of Human Rights
(EOHR) has been very active in trying to monitor the elections: here is their Report #1 and Report #2. More may appear.

Human Rights Watch has a report here. Their Deputy Director, Joe Stork, was briefly detained by police in the Delta.

Independent press accounts can be found here and here. A Muslim Brotherhood version here.

More as it emerges.
You have read this article Egypt / elections / Muslim Brotherhood with the title Muslim Brotherhood. You can bookmark this page URL https://ogbcommunity.blogspot.com/2010/11/election-complaints-growing.html. Thanks!

Labels

1956 Suez War 1973 War 1st Amendment About the Blog Abraham Abu Dhabi Afghanistan agriculture Ahmadinejad Ahmed Mansour airlines Al-Jazeera Al-Qa‘ida Algeria Alzheimer’s AmeriCorps ancient history Anwar Sadat ANZACs appliance rebate April 15 AQAP Arab League Arab newspapers Arab World Arab-Americans Arab-Israeli Issues Arabic language archaeology Asads Ashraf Marwan atrazine Ausrtralia Ayman Nour back pain Bahrain bailouts bank assets to GDP bank capital bank guarantees bank nationalisation Barack Obama being a patient Berbers bethlehem bias billionaires biodiversity Biography birther blahs Blankfein blog action day blogs and blogging books BP brain cancer brain injury brainless bratwurst breast cancer breast cancer Britain Buckley v. Valeo Budget 2009 bully business Cairo camels cancer cancer bonds cancer cause cancer cure cancer detection cancer diagnosis cancer research cancer risk cancer treatment Capital Flows carbon footprint care giving Catholic Church censorship CEO pay Chamber of Commerce chemo brain chemotherapy child abuse China chlorine Christmas Citizens United Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission climate change climate science clinical trials coal coal power coffeehouse gossip college colon cancer colonialism communication Congress Constellation Brands Constitution coping Copts corporations corruption coups credibility Credit Crunch credit default swaps CSAs Cuba cure death debt debt crisis defense issues deficits democratization derivatives DFL diet diglossia Diplomacy distractions doctor appointments doctor questions doctors Don Gordon donating Double Dip Druze Dubai Earth Day earthquakes East Asia and the Middle East economics Egypt ElBaradei elbow elections emotions energy Eurozone Growth Eurozone Spreads exercises extinction fairness Fallujah fat fatigue FDR Federal Reserve film Finance First World War Fiscal Stimulus food football Fox News France fraud Friday Prayer friends funding Gallo Gamal Mubarak Garrison Keillor Gaza GCC Geopolitics George W. Bush Ghajar Global Imbalances global warming Golden Rule Goldman Sachs GOP government debt Greece Greenland Gulf oil spill Gulf states Haiti Hajj Hamas Hariri head injury healing Health health care health care reform health insurance healthcare healthcare reform healthiness healthy eating healthy living Hebron hedge funds Helen Thomas helping herbicides Herding Hizbullah holidays holy places http://www.blogger.com/img/blank.ghttp://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gifif http://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gif humanity humor Husni Mubarak IDF Imazighen income tax incompetence Indian Ocean inflation information technology injections insider trading insolvency insurance intelligence Internet Iran Iraq Iraq war Ireland Islam Islamophobia Israel Israeli newspapers Israeli politics Italy Japan Jerusalem Jim Klobuchar Jordan Judaism Jundallah Koch Industries Kurdish issues Kuwait Kyrgyzstan labor lack of sleep languages learning Lebanon Leukimia levothyroxine Libya life lists Lung cancer Maghreb Maldives Manas Maronites masters of manipulation Mauritania Mecca media medical costs medical errors medical history medical information medication MEI MEI Annual Conference meltdown metastatic cancer Middle East Journal Middle Eastern Christians military affairs Minnesota Minnesota GreenCorps Minnesota taxes monetary policy Morocco mortality Mossad Motivasi Muhammad Naguib Muqtada al-Sadr music music videos Muslim Brotherhood mzerim n Napa Nasser national anthems NATO needles Netanyahu New Deal New York New Zealand news NFL nitrogen pollution no-fly zone Non Sequitur normal nostalgia Nowruz nuclear crisis nuclear weapons Obama obituaries ocean acidification oil Oman Omar Suleiman oncologist optimism organic output gap ovarian cancer overscheduled pain Pakistan Palestine Palestinian Authority palliative Pat Robertson patient rights patriotism Pawlenty Pays d'Oc pesticides pink washing Pinot Noir Plan B planning PLO politics Pope Shenouda III Portfolios Prediction Markets prescriptions press freedom price of risk procedures prostate cancer prostitution protests Public Debt Qadhafi Qatar Quantitative Easing Qur'an radioactive iodine Ras al-Khaimah Ray McGovern Reagan recalls Recession recommendations recurrence remembrance Republican Party research revolutions Richard B. Parker rock bands royalty Rush Limbaugh Saad Zaghloul Saddam Hussein safety sanity Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad Satan Saudi Arabia scars Scott Walker Sectarianism settlements Shi‘ism Shin Bet shipping side effects skepticism Skin cancer sleep social justice social networking solar cells solar energy solar power soy Spare Capacity special operations sphagnum moss sports state budget stem cell Stephen Ross Wine Cellars Sterling Streisand Effect stress Stuxnet succession issues Sudan Summits Sunnis Super Bowl support Supreme Court surgery swimming pool Syria Tamazight Target Corp. Target stores tax cuts taxes teaching televangelism television Territorial disputes terrorism testing The ___ Gulf The UK think tanks thyroid cancer Tifinagh time tired Tom Emmer tourism transportation trauma travel Tulocay Winery Tunisia Turkey UAE UK fiscal policy UK Recession unions United Nations universities university US US Administration US Civil War US military US Presidential Election Utah vacation vegetables Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity Veteran's Day video volunteer volunteer work Walid Jumblatt Wall Street water wealth weather Weekend Historical Videos weight loss wellness Western Sahara Wikileaks wine Wisconsin women Woods Hole World War II Yemen YItzhak Rabin young cancer patients Zahi Hawass Zero Bound